The State of Governmentality. Current Issues and Future Challenges
PD Dr. Ulrich Bröckling, Graduate Research Program „Figurations of the Third“, University of Konstanz, Fach D 153, D-78457 Konstanz.
(as of April 2007:
Professor for “Politics, Ethics and Rhetorics”, University of Leipzig, Dept. of
PD Dr. Susanne
Krasmann, Institute for Criminological Research, Department of Social Sciences,
University of Hamburg, Email:
PD Dr. Thomas Lemke, Institute for Social Research, Senckenberganlage 26, D-60325 Frankfurt am Main. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
14.-15. September 2007
EXPOSÉ [pdf ]
The publication of The Foucault Effect:
Studies in Governmentality in 1991 marked the beginning of a growing interest in
the notion of governmentality in the social and political sciences. In the
following years, »governmentality« became a key term that inspired empirical
analyses in different subject areas and academic disciplines. The so-called
studies of governmentality offered quite a different perspective on state theory
and political analysis: They went beyond traditional accounts structured by the
opposition between state and civil society, public and private spheres, freedom
and constraint by focusing on the interplay between processes of subjectivation
and power mechanisms, political rationalities and governmental technologies.
However, the concept of governmentality also engendered serious criticism in recent years which may point to some limitations and shortcomings in this theoretical perspective. 16 years after the publication of The Foucault Effect the workshop shall provide the opportunity to discuss the theoretical and empirical achievements, future perspectives and persisting problems of an analytics of government. It takes up three major themes that encountered discussions and also critical attention in recent years.
1. Beyond the nation state: Sovereignty, bio-politics and trans-nationalisation
The role of repression and violence in governmental practices is mostly underestimated. In this context, this section seeks to reconsider the notion of sovereign power, often presented as an »archaic« form of power, and also its relation to bio-politics as a form of power licensing even violent acts in the name of protecting the people. Further, it is the territorial sovereign state that serves as the implicit or explicit point of reference, whereas political strategies and tactics exercised in the name of security seem to go beyond the scope of national law and according concepts defining the modern nation state. How should transformations of state power and the changing role of law, for example, in the context of security policies and humanitarian interventions be theoretically addressed? How are we to analyse the political role of those Non-Governmental organisations and inter-, supra- and transnational organizations or networks rarely being an object of consideration in governmentality literature?
2. Biological citizenship and the government of life
The two central Foucauldian notions of government and of bio-politics gave rise to separate lines of reception. As a consequence, studies of governmentality often exclude the question of how the government of individuals and populations interacts with biological categories and concepts of life and death, health and disease, normality and pathology. This section focuses on convergences between the questions of embodiment, concepts of nature and life on the one hand and an analytics of government on the other. Is it possible to analyse bio-politics as an »art of government«? How do biological constructions of gender and race relate to conceptions of citizenship? Is there a biological basis for notions of national identity? How are we to conceive the »vital« existence of the citizens within the political rationalities of state agencies? In which sense do biological identities give rise to forms of political articulation and engagement?
3. The economy of government
Foucault took up the formation of a »political economy« as starting point for his considerations of liberal practices of government, an issue that studies of governmentality accommodated in their analyses of present neo-liberalist regimes. They nevertheless rather neglected the question of how to relate current transformations in governmental rationalities and technologies to changes in the capitalist economy. This section seeks to examine the differences and parallels between contemporary accounts of »the« economy and endeavours of »decentring the economy« (William Walters) put forward in the governmentality literature.
Structure and aim of the workshop
Venue: University of Leipzig, Dept. of Political Sciences, September 14-15, 2007.
The international workshop provides a forum for the discussion of the current state of governmentality and the prospects of an analytics of government in a critical exchange of scholars from Germany and abroad. .
Three speakers per section will be invited for a paper presentation, followed by a commentary and a short reply by the author. To leave sufficient room for discussion, the papers will be circulated prior to the workshop. The number of participants will be restricted to 25. A publication of the papers is planned.
Deadline for paper submission: June 30, 2007.
Panel 1: Mitchell Dean (Syndey), William Walters (Ottawa), Wolfgang Fach (Leipzig)
Panel 2: Herbert Gottweis (Wien), Didier Fassin (Paris), Petra Gehring (Darmstadt)
Panel 3: Peter Miller (London), Urs Stäheli (Basel), Stephan Lessenich (Jena)
Workshop language is English.
The workshop is funded by the Research Initiative “Cultural Theory and Theory of the political Imaginary” at the University of Konstanz.
14th September 2007
9.15 - 9.30
Welcome and introduction to the workshop by the organizers
Panel 1: Beyond the nation state: Sovereignty, bio-politics and trans-nationalisation
9.30 - 10.30
Mitchell Dean (Sydney): Friedrich Balke (Cologne)
10.30 - 11.30
William Walters (Ottawa): Lars Thorup Larsen (Aarhus)
Bob Jessop (Lancaster): Martin Saar (Frankfurt/Main)
12.45 – 14.15 Lunch Break
Panel 2: Biological citizenship and the government of life
14.15 - 15.15
Herbert Gottweis (Vienna): Peter Wehling (Augsburg)
15.15 – 16.15
Didier Fassin (Paris): Monica Greco (London)
Petra Gehring (Darmstadt): Stefanie Graefe (Hamburg)
20.00 Conference dinner
15th September 2007
Panel 3: The economy of government
9.15 - 10.15
Peter Miller (London): Ute Tellmann (Basel)
10.15 - 11.15
Urs Stäheli (Basel): Wolfgang Fach (Leipzig)
11.30 - 12.30
Stephan Lessenich (Jena): Sven Opitz (Basel)
Resume and end of workshop